2024 Update: 10 Real-Life Examples of HIPAA Violations
10 HIPAA Blunders You Need to Know!
The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) is a landmark federal law enacted by the U.S. government in 1996, specifically designed to address the unique privacy and security concerns within the healthcare industry.
With its primary objective to safeguard the confidentiality and integrity of patient health information, HIPAA plays a crucial role in ensuring that sensitive data remains protected.
HIPAA is structured around two principal rules: the Privacy Rule and the Security Rule.
The Privacy Rule establishes foundational principles for maintaining patient privacy, while the Security Rule builds upon this framework by mandating that covered entities — such as hospitals and other healthcare organizations — implement both technical and non-technical safeguards to protect electronic Protected Health Information (e-PHI).
In addition, the Breach Notification Rule requires that HIPAA-covered entities promptly inform affected individuals and relevant parties in the event of a data breach or security incident.
This rule underscores the importance of transparency and timely communication in maintaining trust and compliance within the healthcare sector.
Understanding HIPAA Violations
A HIPAA violation occurs when a healthcare organization, its business associates, or any other party involved in handling patient information fails to comply with the strict privacy, security, or breach notification rules outlined by HIPAA.
These rules are designed to protect the confidentiality and integrity of sensitive health information, and any failure to follow them can result in a violation.
HIPAA violations can happen in various ways, such as unauthorized access to patient records, improper handling of electronic health information, or not providing timely notifications in the event of a data breach.
Such violations can have serious consequences, including fines, penalties, and damage to the organization’s reputation.
If someone believes that a HIPAA violation has occurred, they can file a complaint with the Office for Civil Rights (OCR), which is part of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
The OCR is tasked with investigating these complaints, ensuring that healthcare providers and their partners are following HIPAA regulations. Through these investigations, the OCR works to enforce compliance and protect patient rights across the healthcare system.
Top 10 HIPAA Violations: Real-Life Examples
Many HIPAA violations occur because employees in hospitals or medical institutions are not fully aware of the rules or what actions may violate them.
A 2021 survey revealed that 24% of employees in the healthcare sector had not received security awareness training, which significantly increases the risk of violations.
The consequences of these violations can be severe, leading to substantial financial penalties and even imprisonment.
To better understand the impact, let’s explore 10 real-life examples of HIPAA violations in detail.
1. Unauthorized Disclosure of Patient Information by Healthcare Employees
HIPAA’s Privacy Rule safeguards all types of patient information, whether it’s written, spoken, or electronic. It allows patients to control who can access their health data and requires explicit consent before any information can be shared.
When healthcare employees access, discuss or share patient information without proper authorization, they are violating HIPAA’s privacy protections. This type of violation is one of the most frequent among healthcare professionals and can lead to serious consequences, including the possibility of imprisonment. The following real-life case illustrates the gravity of such actions.
Case 1: Unauthorized Access to Britney Spears’s Medical Records
In 2008, when Britney Spears was admitted to the UCLA Medical Center in Los Angeles, 13 employees were dismissed for accessing her medical records without permission.
Additionally, six physicians were suspended. This case demonstrates the severe penalties that can result from breaching patient privacy, even for high-profile individuals.
2. When Medical Records End Up in the Wrong Hands
Healthcare professionals frequently need to carry patient information on their laptops, mobile devices, and tablets to perform their daily duties. While this is often necessary, it also raises security concerns. A common HIPAA violation occurs when these devices are stolen, leading to the exposure of sensitive patient data.
Although theft of electronic devices is typically not covered by insurance, there are preventive measures to protect the data, such as encryption, password protection, and multi-factor authentication. To highlight the importance of these safeguards, consider the following case.
Case 2: Children’s Medical Center of Dallas Loses $3.2 Million
The Children’s Medical Center of Dallas faced several HIPAA violations, according to Health Care IT News. In one notable incident, 3,800 pieces of Protected Health Information (PHI) were lost when a Blackberry device was stolen. The device was neither password-protected nor encrypted.
As a result of these security failures, the medical center had to pay a significant fine. The case exemplifies how critical it is to ensure electronic devices are properly secured to prevent such costly and damaging breaches in healthcare.
3. Using Unsecured Methods to Share PHI
HIPAA’s Security Rule requires that patient information be shared and stored using secure methods to ensure privacy. Sharing health data over unsecured channels can expose it to unauthorized access and cyber threats.
Methods such as texting, video calls, personal emails, or common file-sharing services are considered insecure for transmitting patient information. Using these methods can result in electronic Protected Health Information (e-PHI) being compromised.
Case 3: Exposure of 11,000 Patient Records Through Unsecure File Sharing
Lanap & Dental Implants of Pennsylvania faced a HIPAA violation after uploading about 11,000 dental records to a torrent file-sharing site. These records were publicly accessible online for four years without encryption. The data was only obfuscated, which allowed individuals with basic technical skills to access it. This incident highlights the dangers of using insecure methods to handle patient information.
4. Risks of Sharing Patient Information on Social Media
Healthcare facilities and individuals must avoid posting any patient health information on social media platforms, such as online reviews, LinkedIn, or rating sites.
Even if the patient’s name is not explicitly mentioned, sharing health-related details online is considered an unauthorized disclosure of Protected Health Information (PHI).
Posting PHI on social media, whether intentional or accidental, breaches HIPAA regulations and jeopardizes patient privacy.
Such actions can result in severe consequences, including legal penalties and damage to the credibility of healthcare providers.
Healthcare professionals need to be vigilant about these privacy rules to safeguard patient information and uphold trust.
Case 4: Health Center Discloses PHI in Response to Negative Review
Manasa Health Center, a psychiatric service provider in New Jersey, faced a significant HIPAA violation when it disclosed a patient’s protected health information in response to a negative online review.
This action violated the HIPAA Privacy Rules by revealing patient details without authorization and failing to enforce appropriate privacy policies.
Following an investigation by the Office for Civil Rights (OCR), Manasa Health Center was found at fault and had to pay $30,000 to settle the case with the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS).
The center also agreed to implement a corrective action plan to prevent future violations.
5. Unauthorized Access to Patient Files
HIPAA strictly prohibits accessing patient health records without explicit patient authorization or under pretenses.
This rule applies universally to all individuals, including doctors and healthcare staff.
Even if the accessed information is not misused, stolen, or sold, unauthorized access still constitutes a violation.
Written consent is required to access Protected Health Information (PHI), and without it, any access is considered a breach of HIPAA regulations. Consider the following example to understand this better.
Case 5: Doctor Faces Jail Time for Unauthorized Access
Dr. H, who had recently moved to the U.S. from China and had been involved in research, accessed patient records during his notice period out of curiosity about his colleagues and celebrities.
Although he did not use the information for personal gain or share it with others, he accessed these records without proper authorization.
Unaware of HIPAA’s strict access rules, Dr. H was charged with a HIPAA violation after his employment ended.
He was sentenced to four months in jail and fined $2,000. This case highlights the importance of adhering to HIPAA’s access requirements, regardless of intentions.
6. Risks of Using Insecure Third-Party Technology
Many healthcare providers utilize third-party tracking applications to gather user data and monitor online activities, aiming to enhance the patient experience.
However, if these third-party technologies are not adequately secure, they can lead to serious issues such as identity theft, harassment, stalking, and data leaks.
Case 6: Hospital Websites Expose Patient Data to Facebook
An investigation by The Markup revealed that 33 of Newsweek’s top 100 hospitals used a tracking tool called Meta Pixel.
This tool transmitted sensitive patient information to Facebook whenever users interacted with appointment scheduling features on hospital websites.
The Meta Pixel tool collected detailed, identifiable health data, including information about medical conditions, prescriptions, and appointments, and shared it with Facebook along with IP addresses.
David Holtzman, a health privacy consultant and former senior privacy adviser at HHS, remarked that while it cannot be definitively confirmed as a HIPAA violation, it is highly likely to be one.
This case underscores the critical need for healthcare providers to ensure that third-party technologies are secure to protect patient privacy.
7. Failure to Notify About Breaches promptly
The HIPAA Breach Notification Rule mandates that affected parties must be informed about a breach without delay, and no later than 60 days from discovering the incident.
Covered entities are required to provide details about the type of information compromised, the protective measures taken, and contact information for follow-up.
Failure to notify affected individuals and the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) within the specified time frame constitutes a HIPAA violation and can result in significant fines. Here is an example of such a violation:
Case 7: OSU-CHS Fined $875,000 for Delayed Breach Notification
On January 5, 2018, Oklahoma State University — Center for Health Sciences (OSU-CHS) reported a HIPAA breach involving a hacker who accessed a web server containing the ePHI of 279,865 individuals.
The breach was initially reported as having occurred on November 7, 2017, but investigations revealed that the breach began on March 9, 2016.
The delay in notifying affected individuals and HHS about the breach resulted in a substantial HIPAA violation.
OSU-CHS was required to settle with HHS by paying $875,000 and implementing a robust corrective action plan, with ongoing monitoring for two years.
This case highlights the critical importance of timely breach notification in maintaining HIPAA compliance.
8. Failure to Implement Effective Risk Management
An effective risk management process is crucial for healthcare organizations to safeguard patient information.
Without conducting regular and comprehensive risk assessments and internal audits of access controls and processes, organizations remain unaware of their vulnerabilities, leaving them exposed to potential attacks.
HIPAA’s Security Rule requires all covered entities to perform an organization-wide risk analysis. According to the HHS website, this process involves:
- Assessing potential risks to electronic Protected Health Information (e-PHI);
- Implementing appropriate security measures to mitigate identified risks;
- Documenting the security measures and their justifications;
- Ensuring continuous and adequate security protections.
Case 8: DHSS Fined $1.7 Million for Inadequate Risk Management
In 2012, the Alaska Department of Health and Social Services (DHSS) was found in violation of several HIPAA regulations due to failures in risk management.
An investigation revealed that DHSS did not have proper policies or security protocols in place to protect patient information. A significant issue was their lack of risk analysis and inadequate measures to manage identified risks.
As a result, DHSS had to settle the case with a $1.7 million fine. This case underscores the importance of implementing and maintaining a robust risk management process to comply with HIPAA requirements and protect sensitive patient data.
9. Lack of an Incident Response Plan
Under HIPAA’s Security Rule, healthcare organizations are required to take prompt and reasonable steps to address any issues or breaches that compromise electronic Protected Health Information (e-PHI).
This includes swiftly addressing security lapses to ensure that patient information remains protected.
Without a clear incident response plan, organizations may find themselves in chaos during a data breach.
The absence of a structured response can lead to delays, further spread of the breach, and additional harm to patients, potentially resulting in legal and financial repercussions.
An effective incident response plan is essential for timely breach notification and for minimizing the impact of a breach.
Case 9: UMMC Fined $2.75 Million for Poor Response to Breaches
The University of Mississippi Medical Center (UMMC) was fined $2.75 million for a HIPAA violation involving the unsecured ePHI of around 10,000 individuals.
Investigations revealed that UMMC had been aware of security risks for some time but failed to address them until after the breach occurred.
Additionally, UMMC did not notify the affected individuals whose ePHI was accessed or disclosed, leading to further violations.
This case highlights the critical need for a robust incident response plan to effectively manage and mitigate the impact of data breaches.
10. Improper Disposal of Electronic Protected Health Information (e-PHI)
When patient medical records reach the end of their retention period or are no longer needed, healthcare institutions are required to dispose of them securely.
This means ensuring that the records — whether digital or paper — cannot be read or accessed by unauthorized individuals.
For physical records, methods such as shredding or pulping are appropriate. For electronic records, techniques like degaussing, physically destroying portable devices, or securely wiping data are essential.
Failure to follow proper disposal methods can lead to significant fines, as illustrated by the following case:
Case 10: Cornell Prescription Pharmacy Fined $125,000
Cornell Prescription Pharmacy, a small pharmacy in Denver, faced a $125,000 fine from the HHS for violating the HIPAA Privacy Rule due to improper disposal of Protected Health Information (PHI).
The Office for Civil Rights (OCR) discovered that Cornell had not implemented necessary written policies and procedures for the disposal of patient information.
An investigation revealed that documents containing the PHI of 1,610 patients were disposed of insecurely, exposing sensitive information.
In addition to the monetary penalty, Cornell agreed to a corrective action plan to address the identified compliance deficiencies.
Conclusion
Understanding and adhering to HIPAA regulations is crucial for safeguarding patient information and maintaining trust within the healthcare system.
The real-world examples discussed highlight the diverse ways in which HIPAA violations can occur and the severe consequences that follow.
From unauthorized access to improper disposal of e-PHI, each case underscores the importance of compliance with HIPAA’s stringent privacy and security rules.
Ensuring that healthcare organizations have robust policies, effective risk management strategies, and a well-defined incident response plan can mitigate these risks.
Regular training, secure technology practices, and timely breach notifications are essential components of maintaining compliance and protecting sensitive patient data.
As these examples show, the cost of failing to meet HIPAA standards can be substantial, both financially and reputationally.
By learning from these cases and implementing best practices, healthcare providers can better safeguard patient information and avoid the pitfalls that lead to costly violations.
Ready to Streamline Compliance?
Building a secure foundation for your startup is crucial, but navigating the complexities of achieving compliance can be a hassle, especially for small teams.
SecureSlate offers a simpler solution:
- Affordable: Expensive compliance software shouldn’t be the barrier. Our affordable plans start at just $99/month.
- Focus on Your Business, Not Paperwork: Automate tedious tasks and free up your team to focus on innovation and growth.
- Gain Confidence and Credibility: Our platform guides you through the process, ensuring you meet all essential requirements, and giving you peace of mind.
Get Started in Just 3 Minutes
It only takes 3 minutes to sign up and see how our platform can streamline your compliance journey.
